GTA 6 Benedict Halifax: Trust Him, and Should You Spare Him?
Every Benedict Halifax choice in GTA 6's Dubious Provenance: give him the statue, trust him or not, and why sparing him gets you his '32 Hustler.

Spare Benedict Halifax. At the end of the Chapter 3 mission Dubious Provenance you get to shoot or spare the shady art dealer, and sparing him is better in every way: you keep a clean criminal profile, avoid the police and get to loot his garage, including a '32 Hustler. Here's every Halifax choice in order. Light spoilers for Dubious Provenance.
Quick answers
| Choice | Best option | Why |
|---|---|---|
| Give him the statue? | Yes | Not giving it only delays the mission |
| Trust him (at the motel)? | Don't trust | Skips straight to the finale |
| Shoot or spare? | Spare | Garage loot and no criminal-profile hit |
| He won't call back? | Normal | Keep playing; part 2 opens by itself |
Choice 1: give Halifax the statue?
In Dubious Provenance, Jason and Lucia take the statue to an antiques store in Capri to sell it. The owner won't touch it, but an art dealer, Benedict Halifax, offers to help outside.
- Give it to him: he hands you a nice watch as collateral, then disappears for a while.
- Keep it: you hold on to the statue, but to finish the mission you'll have to come back to Capri and hand it over anyway.
Halifax won't answer: is it a bug?
No. He ignores your calls on purpose: his voicemail is scripted. Keep playing Chapter 3, and the second part opens on its own after the missions First Impressions or Crosstown Traffic. If you refused his deal, call him yourself before Chapter 3 ends.
Choice 2: trust Halifax?
After a few in-game days, Jason and Lucia track him down at a motel, in room 110. He asks for more time with the statue.
- Trust him: he ghosts you again, and the antiques store owner, Evelyn Andrews, eventually calls to tell you where he is.
- Don't trust him: he takes you to the antiques store straight away, so the finale starts sooner.
Choice 3: shoot or spare Halifax?
After a chase through Capri, you're alone with him and have to decide.
- Shoot him: it counts as extreme, avoidable violence and hurts your criminal profile, and the police arrive while you're stuck in Capri's narrow streets.
- Spare him: he runs off and is never seen again. You get the statue back and can loot his garage for free: his Vapid '32 Hustler (registering it as your car costs $21,000), plus cash and jewellery to sell to a fence.
Other story choices: kill or spare Arnold and Donnie or Brian. To sell the jewellery, see our fence guide.
Sources
Based on 3 videos and articles. Here are the main ones, with credit to their creators.
Keep reading
Image: Rockstar GamesGTA 6 Hey Arnold: Should You Kill or Spare Arnold?
Nov 19, 2026 · 3 min read · 5 sources
Image: Rockstar GamesGTA 6: How to Save, Autosave and Replaying Missions
Updated Nov 21, 2026 · 4 min read · 14 sources
Image: Rockstar GamesGTA 6: Sell to Donnie or Brian? And Can You Save Donnie?
Nov 21, 2026 · 3 min read · 4 sources
Image: Rockstar GamesGTA 6 Not Working? Live Launch Problems Tracker and Fixes
Updated Nov 20, 2026 · 5 min read · 19 sources
Image: Rockstar GamesHow to Repair Jason's House in GTA 6 (All 4 Repairs)
Nov 19, 2026 · 3 min read · 5 sources
Image: Rockstar GamesGTA 6 Operation Furball: How to Save Chase and Which Reward to Pick
Nov 22, 2026 · 2 min read · 2 sources