GTA 6 Hey Arnold: Should You Kill or Spare Arnold?
GTA 6's Hey Arnold mission ends with a choice: kill Arnold or let him go. What each option does to your Criminal Profile, the reward and the walkthrough.

Hey Arnold! is the first real moral choice in GTA 6. At the end of this Chapter 1 mission for Brian, Arnold gives up and you decide whether Jason kills him or lets him walk. Short answer: spare him. Neither option changes the main story much, but sparing Arnold is the better choice for your Criminal Profile.
Quick answers
| Question | Answer |
|---|---|
| Which mission? | Hey Arnold! (Meet Brian), Chapter 1 |
| When does it start? | After Pipework: Brian calls you a few minutes later |
| What does killing him do? | You get the "Hardened Criminal" rating, which pushes your Criminal Profile the wrong way |
| What does sparing him do? | You get the "Restrained" rating, which helps your Criminal Profile |
| Does the reward change? | No, Brian's payout is the same either way |
| Does Arnold come back? | Unclear: guides disagree |

How to start Hey Arnold
Finish the Chapter 1 mission Pipework (collecting Mandy's rent) and wait. A few minutes later Brian Heder phones Jason, and the mission marker appears in Key Lento. It's a main story mission, so you can't skip it. You'll find it in our full mission list.
Walkthrough
- Meet Brian at the pool bar in the south of Key Lento, get into his car and wait for him.
- Pick up Cal at the liquor store nearby.
- Head for the search area southwest of Key Lento, on Maroon Key. Arnold is waiting by a small building, the meeting goes wrong and his people open fire.
- Chase Arnold. He drives off with henchmen on motorbikes shooting at you. Aim with L1/LB, shoot with R1/RB, and press L3 + R3 to slow time with Focus. The bridge ramps on the route count as stunt jumps, and they stay ticked off on your map.
- Catch him at the water. Arnold ditches the car, runs for the docks and surrenders. Now you choose.
Kill Arnold: what happens
Shoot him and the mission ends with the "Hardened Criminal" rating, which drags your Criminal Profile toward the violent end. Arnold is gone for good. You don't get any extra money for it.
Spare Arnold: what happens
Let him go and he swims off. You get the "Restrained" rating, which nudges your profile toward the good side. Jason tells Brian that Arnold won't cause any more trouble, and Brian accepts it. The payout is the same as if you'd killed him.
Will Arnold come back later? Sources don't agree. PowerPyx's walkthrough says he leaves for good and both endings play out the same. Dexerto says a spared Arnold can turn up again in a later story mission. We'll update this once it's confirmed.
Which should you choose?
Spare him. The story barely changes either way and the money is identical, so the only real difference is your Criminal Profile, and "Restrained" is the rating you want. A cleaner profile matters because the worst ratings change how the police treat you, and the very bottom one is permanent. Our Criminal Profile guide explains the five levels. Several videos show both endings side by side if you want to see them before you choose.
If you want to try both, you can replay the mission later: see our replay and save slots guide.
Sources
Based on 5 videos and articles. Here are the main ones, with credit to their creators.
- ArticleGTA 6 Hey Arnold! (Meet Brian) WalkthroughPowerPyx
- ArticleShould you kill or spare Arnold in GTA 6?Dexerto
- VideoGTA 6 - Kill Arnold Vs. Let Him Go (Both Outcomes)Sirloin
- VideoGTA 6 – You can spare or take out Arnold! (both endings)KingAlexHD
- VideoShould You Spare Or Kill Arnold In Grand Theft Auto 6Gamers Heroes
Keep reading
Image: Rockstar GamesGTA 6 Criminal Profile Explained: All 5 Levels
Nov 18, 2026 · 3 min read · 5 sources
Image: Rockstar GamesGTA 6 Mission List: All Chapters and How Many Missions
Nov 19, 2026 · 3 min read · 3 sources
Image: Rockstar GamesGTA 6 Phone and Apps: Every App and What It Does
Updated Nov 19, 2026 · 7 min read · 15 sources
Image: Rockstar GamesDoes GTA 6 Have First-Person Mode? How to Use It
Nov 19, 2026 · 2 min read · 7 sources
Image: Rockstar GamesDoes GTA 6 Have Heists? Robberies and Money Explained
Updated Nov 19, 2026 · 7 min read · 8 sources
Image: Rockstar GamesDoes GTA 6 Have Cloud Saves and Cross-Progression?
Nov 3, 2026 · 3 min read · 8 sources